Newsletter

Google Analytics 4 review: free and powerful, and when a simpler tool is better

Google Analytics 4 costs nothing and does more than most small sites will ever use: events, conversions, audiences and a direct link to Google Ads. The trade-offs are a steep learning curve, data kept for 14 months at most, and Google processing your visitors' data.

This review explains what GA4 does well, its real limits, and what the paid Analytics 360 adds. It also covers when a simple, EU-hosted tool such as Plausible or a self-hosted Matomo is the better choice. The picker shows which one fits your site.

· 5 min read · Review

Bar chart comparing GA4 free, Plausible 9 dollars and Matomo Cloud 29 a month

What GA4 is

Google Analytics 4 (GA4) is Google's free web and app analytics. Everything it records is an event: a page view, a scroll, a click on a buy button. You mark the events that matter as key events (what used to be called conversions), then see where your visitors came from, what they did, and which channels bring the visitors who buy or sign up. It replaced Universal Analytics, which Google switched off.

For most websites the question isn't whether GA4 can do the job. It almost always can. The questions are whether you will learn it well enough to use it, and whether you are comfortable with how it handles your visitors' data.

What GA4 does well

  • It is free, with no traffic limit for normal websites.
  • Events and key events: once set up, you can track nearly any action and see which channels lead to it.
  • Google Ads and Search Console links: if you advertise on Google, the audiences and conversions flow straight back into your campaigns.
  • Explorations: funnels, paths and segment comparisons for deeper questions.
  • BigQuery export, so analysts can query raw event data with SQL.

The limits that matter

Google's own documentation lists the limits of the free version (called "standard") next to the paid Analytics 360:

  • Data retention: detailed event data is kept for 2 or 14 months on the free version, and up to 50 months on 360. Standard reports keep longer totals, but year-on-year explorations need the 14-month setting. Switch it on, because the default is shorter.
  • Sampling: explorations are sampled above 10 million events per query on the free version.
  • BigQuery: the free version's daily export is capped at 1 million events.
  • Custom definitions: 50 event-scoped custom dimensions and 30 key events per property.

Analytics 360 raises these limits and adds service-level agreements. Google doesn't publish a price for it; it is sold through Google and its partners and is aimed at large companies.

Privacy and consent

GA4 uses cookies and sends visitor data to Google. In the EU and UK that usually means asking visitors for consent first, and visitors who say no aren't measured in the normal way. GA4 has features to soften this (Consent Mode, IP data not stored, regional data controls), but you still need a consent banner and a privacy policy that covers it. Ask your own privacy adviser what applies to you; this review isn't legal advice.

That is the main reason many small European sites look at alternatives that don't use cookies and keep data in the EU.

GA4 or a simpler tool?

The alternatives in short

Plausible: simple and EU-hosted

Plausible is a paid, privacy-first analytics tool with one dashboard page instead of dozens of reports. It says it is made and hosted in the EU, uses no cookies, and processes visitor data only on servers owned by European companies. Its Starter plan is $9 a month for up to 10,000 monthly page views on one site, Growth is $14 for up to 3 sites, and Business $19 for up to 10. Prices rise with traffic, and there is a 30-day free trial with no card needed. It does far less than GA4, which is the point.

Matomo: the closest like-for-like

Matomo is the most complete open-source alternative to Google Analytics. Matomo On-Premise is free with unlimited users and hits if you host it yourself, so you decide where the data lives. Matomo Cloud starts at 29 a month (excluding tax) for 50,000 hits a month across up to 30 websites, hosted in Frankfurt. Its pricing page doesn't name the currency. It is heavier to learn than Plausible, but closer to GA4 in what it can do.

Who GA4 is for

Use GA4 if you advertise on Google or need detailed funnels. Use Plausible if you mainly want to know your traffic and top pages without cookie banners. Use Matomo if you need GA-level detail with your data under your own control.

Many sites run two tools: a light one for everyday traffic numbers, and GA4 only where Google Ads needs it. Before adding any of them, decide which three or four numbers you will actually check every week. That decides the tool better than any feature list.

What to look for

  • Set GA4's data retention to 14 months on day one.
  • Mark your key events (sign-ups, purchases, contact forms) right away; GA4 is much less useful without them.
  • Check what your consent banner does to your numbers before comparing tools.
  • Price privacy tools by page views, and check how much traffic you really get per month.

Sources

Three options

Examples that match this guide, not tested reviews. Links go straight to each vendor; nobody pays to be picked. Prices from the vendors' own pricing pages, checked 17 Nov. They change, so confirm before you buy.